The 4 Best Hotels in Edgartown, Martha’s Vineyard
Few summer destinations on the East Coast feel as timeless as Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard. With its white captain’s houses, sailboat-filled harbor, and hydrangea-lined streets, the town is the island’s most polished and iconic place to stay.
Whether you’re visiting for a long weekend or planning a full Vineyard summer escape, choosing the right hotel can shape the entire experience. From historic waterfront properties to charming boutique inns and relaxed oceanside resorts, these are the Edgartown hotels everyone wants to stay at.
Below are four of our favorite places to stay in Edgartown — each offering a different way to experience Martha’s Vineyard.
Courtesy of Faraway
A stylish boutique stay right in the center of town, Faraway Martha’s Vineyard has quickly become one of the island’s most stylish places to stay. The property blends several historic Edgartown buildings into a design-forward hotel with breezy interiors and a lively courtyard.
It’s especially popular with younger travelers and couples thanks to its central location and social atmosphere.
Location: Downtown Edgartown
Dining: Pelican Club restaurant & bar
Amenities:
• Heated outdoor pool
• Fitness area
• Beautiful outdoor courtyard lounge
• Complimentary bikes
• Fire pits and evening gathering spaces
• Walkable to shops, harbor, and restaurants
Courtesy of Harbor View Hotel
One of the most iconic hotels on Martha’s Vineyard, Harbor View Hotel sits just across from Edgartown Lighthouse and offers sweeping views of the harbor. Originally opened in 1891, the property has been thoughtfully restored into a refined coastal resort while preserving its classic New England character.
This is the quintessential Edgartown stay — steps from downtown restaurants and shops, yet perfectly positioned for quiet harbor views and sunset strolls.
Location: Waterfront, across from Edgartown Lighthouse
Dining: Bettini Restaurant, Roxy Pool Bar, Behind The View Cocktail Lounge
Amenities:
• Heated outdoor pool with loungers and cabanas
• Modern fitness center
• Complimentary bikes
• Fire pits and evening gathering spaces
• Harbor-view rooms and suites
• Walkable to shops, harbor, and restaurants
Courtesy Winnetu Oceanside Resort
Located just outside Edgartown on South Beach, Winnetu Oceanside Resort offers something unique on the island: a true beachfront resort experience. Spacious suites, family-friendly amenities, and direct beach access make it ideal for travelers who want to spend most of their time by the ocean.
A vintage shuttle connects guests to Edgartown throughout the day, making it easy to enjoy both beach relaxation and the town’s restaurants and shops.
Location: South Beach, just outside Edgartown
Dining: The Dunes restaurant, Poolside lunch & bar service
Amenities:
• Direct beach access
• Large outdoor pool with loungers and cabanas
• Full fitness center
• Bikes available
• Family activities and kids programs
• Complimentary shuttle to Edgartown
• Large suites and cottages
Courtesy The Charlotte Inn
For something more intimate and romantic, The Charlotte Inn offers one of the most distinctive stays on Martha’s Vineyard. Built in 1864, the inn feels like stepping into another era, with antique-filled rooms, candlelit spaces, and beautifully maintained gardens.
Unlike larger hotels, the Charlotte Inn is intentionally quiet and refined, creating a peaceful retreat right in the heart of Edgartown.
Location: Downtown Edgartown
Dining: The Terrace Restaurant
Amenities:
• Historic rooms with antiques
• Garden courtyards and patios
• Walkable to harbor and downtown
