The Best Places to Stay in the Hamptons (2026)
The Hamptons may be known for sprawling summer houses, but the East End also has a small collection of exceptional boutique hotels and waterfront resorts. From oceanfront Montauk escapes to historic seaside retreats and quiet countryside hideaways, these properties capture the best of the Hamptons.
Below are eight of the most memorable luxury stays across Montauk, Amagansett, Hampton Bays, and Shelter Island.
Courtesy The Reform Club
Location: Amagansett
Vibe: Private estate-style boutique hotel
Highlights
Cottage-style accommodations set across landscaped grounds
Heated pool, tennis courts, and garden dining
Quiet, residential atmosphere
The Reform Club feels like staying at a beautiful private summer estate. Guests move between cottages, gardens, and the pool area, creating a relaxed and secluded Hamptons experience.
Best for: privacy and low-key luxury.
Courtesy of Montauk Yacht Club
Location: Montauk
Vibe: Marina resort
Highlights
Waterfront marina and boating culture
Multiple pools and restaurants
Recently renovated rooms and spa
Montauk Yacht Club offers a lively marina setting with expansive waterfront views. Guests can dock boats, enjoy harborfront dining, or relax by the pools overlooking the marina.
Best for: boating weekends and social summer stays.
Courtesy Cape Resorts
Location: Shelter Island
Vibe: Historic seaside resort
Highlights
Waterfront setting overlooking Peconic Bay
Classic white-clapboard architecture
Kayaking, tennis, and lawn games
Originally opened in 1927, The Pridwin feels like a nostalgic American summer resort. Its ferry-access location on Shelter Island makes it quieter and more secluded than many Hamptons hotels.
Best for: peaceful coastal escapes.
Courtesy Gurney’s Resorts
Location: Montauk
Vibe: Iconic oceanfront resort
Highlights
One of the only true oceanfront resorts in the Hamptons
Private beach club and multiple waterfront restaurants
The famous Seawater Spa with indoor seawater pool
Gurney’s is the Hamptons’ most recognizable resort, perched directly on the Atlantic in Montauk. Nearly every room faces the ocean, and summer days revolve around the beach club, sunset cocktails, and long afternoons by the water.
Best for: classic Hamptons beach weekends.
Courtesy Marram Montauk
Location: Montauk
Vibe: Minimalist beachfront boutique hotel
Highlights
Direct beach access
Sunrise yoga and surf lessons
Bonfires and oceanfront gathering spaces
Marram is one of Montauk’s most stylish stays, pairing modern coastal design with a relaxed surf-town atmosphere. The experience centers around the beach, with communal bonfires and wellness programming.
Best for: laid-back coastal luxury.
Courtesy of Hero Beach Club
Location: Montauk
Vibe: Relaxed beachfront boutique hotel
Highlights
Heated outdoor pool and lounge areas
Fire pits and beach access
Yoga classes and wellness events
Hero Beach Club blends Montauk’s surf culture with a stylish boutique hotel atmosphere. The outdoor spaces make it an ideal place to unwind after a day on the beach.
Best for: relaxed Montauk weekends.
Courtesy of Canoe Place Inn
Location: Hampton Bays
Vibe: Historic Hamptons inn
Highlights
One of the oldest inns in the United States
Beautifully restored historic property
Garden pool and renowned restaurant
Dating back centuries, Canoe Place Inn blends historic charm with modern luxury. It’s one of the most elegant inns on the East End, offering refined rooms and a peaceful garden setting.
Best for: a classic Hamptons getaway.
Courtesy of The Roundtree
Location: Amagansett
Vibe: Quiet luxury boutique hotel
Highlights
Beautiful cottages and historic barn suites
Fire pits, gardens, and complimentary bikes
Walkable to Amagansett village
The Roundtree is one of the most refined boutique stays in the Hamptons, combining understated interiors with a tranquil countryside setting.
Best for: serene Hamptons weekends.
